Forced smiling can leave people less happy, study finds

A smile on demand can lift the mood, but doing it repeatedly or under threat of a penalty can have the opposite effect, according to new psychology research that challenges the idea that deliberate smiling is always beneficial.
The study, published on 1 October in the Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, was led by Nicholas Coles, a psychology professor at the University of Florida, with Annabel Dang and Joao Francisco Goes Braga Takayanagi. Coles had spent years studying whether facial expressions shape emotions, and his earlier work supported the view that smiling improves mood. His own experience in customer service seemed to point the other way: he said he was once written up at a Florida theme park for failing to keep smiling at work.
To test the contradiction, the team recruited 1,201 people for an online experiment, of whom 1,174 were included in the analysis. Participants viewed either pleasant images, such as kittens and flowers, or disturbing ones showing theft and animal cruelty. Some were told to smile, while others were free to react naturally. Depending on their group, they did the task once or 10 times.
To mimic workplace pressure, half were warned they could lose $2 of their $6 payment if they did not follow the smiling instructions. In the end everyone received the full amount. Participants rated their happiness after each task.
Among those who saw unpleasant images, a single posed smile gave a small boost to happiness, even for those warned about losing money. Repeating the smile weakened the effect, and combining repetition with the financial threat wiped it out.
The results were different for pleasant images. A single smile made little difference, but repeated smiling or the risk of a penalty left participants less happy than those who reacted naturally, and further analysis showed more irritation and anger. Coles said a single unforced smile reproduces what laboratory studies have found, but that adding the repetition and consequences of real working life reverses the result.
The findings suggest that research showing the benefits of smiling does not necessarily apply to people who must look cheerful all day. Coles pointed to Target, which was criticised over a policy requiring staff to smile when customers came within a set distance. He argued such rules restrict workers’ freedom to express their genuine feelings and pressure customers to respond in kind.
After years of researching ways to raise happiness, Coles also questions society’s heavy emphasis on feeling happier than we are, and said there is far less emphasis on being content with what we have.
Source: SciTectDaily.