View notices
The Fiduciary GazetteA newspaper of record for the professions
← News

Zille and Mashaba: The DA–ActionSA coalition dilemma

By Africa Newsdesk · 6 November 2026
Zille and Mashaba: The DA–ActionSA coalition dilemma
Photo: NewsroomZA

ActionSA is likely to become a central player in coalition negotiations after strong local government election results, but party leader Herman Mashaba’s repeated criticism of its past association with the Democratic Alliance could complicate any DA-led arrangement – particularly in Johannesburg.

Preliminary results place ActionSA among the leading parties in Gauteng’s three metropolitan municipalities, with about 22.4% support in Tshwane, 16.8% in Johannesburg and 16.3% in Ekurhuleni. The party has also emerged as the leading party in Laingsburg, where it and the DA each won three seats.

ActionSA has said coalition discussions will be necessary in many of the 105 municipalities it contested, and its negotiators have begun “talks about talks” with other parties. The party says it is open to working with any organisation committed to stable governance, service delivery and anti-corruption.

But Mashaba has made clear that the DA will not receive automatic favoured treatment. Asked about coalitions in Gauteng, he said ActionSA’s “biggest mistake” in 2024 was its association with the DA.

He argued that the relationship damaged ActionSA electorally, with some black voters fearing their support would ultimately benefit the DA, while some DA-leaning voters preferred to vote directly for the DA.

Mashaba’s remarks draw on ActionSA’s difficult experience in Johannesburg’s earlier multiparty coalition governments. He served as Johannesburg mayor from 2016 to 2019, before resigning amid tensions involving the DA. He has since accused the party of obstructing his efforts to govern and contributing to the instability that followed.

That history is likely to weigh heavily on negotiations in Johannesburg, where ActionSA could hold the balance of power. Mashaba has said ActionSA will not enter coalition negotiations until the final results are known, and has indicated that any cooperation with the DA would depend on a change in its leadership, saying the party would need to remove Helen Zille.

The DA, for its part, says it will engage with parties committed to sound financial management, infrastructure delivery and fighting corruption, but has ruled out trading executive positions purely for political power.

The most immediate coalition test may be Laingsburg, where the near-even split between ActionSA and the DA makes cooperation almost unavoidable if either party is to govern. In Tshwane, ActionSA’s strong performance gives it considerable leverage, although a DA-led coalition remains possible if the parties can agree on portfolios and executive roles.

Johannesburg, however, appears set to be the most difficult negotiation. With Mashaba positioning ActionSA as an independent kingmaker rather than a junior coalition partner, a smooth DA–ActionSA pact looks less likely than hard bargaining, a minority administration, or an alternative coalition involving other parties.

Analysts say the broader lesson from ActionSA’s performance is that it now has the electoral weight to demand more than symbolic participation in government. Whether that translates into formal coalitions with the DA will depend less on shared opposition to the ANC than on whether Mashaba believes the DA can offer a stable, credible and politically acceptable governing arrangement.

Sources: Business Day, Sowetan, EWN, Sunday Times, YFM, Daily Maverick, eNCA, Channel Africa.

Share:LinkedIn
Zille and Mashaba: The DA–ActionSA coalition dilemma