US review puts employer-linked benefit deals in the spotlight

The US Department of Labour is reviewing how employers obtain approval for transactions between employee benefit plans and related parties, including insurers the employer owns.
According to the department’s regulatory agenda, the aim is to simplify the process of obtaining exemptions under the US Employee Retirement Income Security Act (Erisa).
One example is an employer using its own captive insurer to reinsure benefits such as group life or disability cover, insurance publication Captive International reports.
Where a deal falls under Erisa’s prohibited-transaction rules, it can proceed only if an exemption applies, whether statutory, class or individual. In earlier exemptions the department has looked for a benefit to plan participants and an independent fiduciary overseeing the deal. As of 17 November, it had yet to publish draft amendments.
The review has no direct effect on South African retirement funds. It is most relevant to South African groups that run employee benefit plans subject to Erisa.
It does invite a comparison with the local rules. Section 7C of the Pension Funds Act requires fund boards to act independently, avoid conflicts of interest and protect members’ interests.
Section 7D requires proper records, including minutes of board resolutions. If a sponsoring employer proposes using a group-linked insurer, those records can show what the board considered, how it dealt with any conflict and why it concluded the arrangement served members. Section 19(5) of the Act also restricts how a fund may lend to, or invest in, the sponsoring employer.
South Africa’s Insurance Act defines a captive insurer as one that insures only the risks of its own group, and it sets separate rules for cell captive insurers.
A fund’s group risk cover is normally written by a licensed life insurer, so a captive could at most reinsure the employer’s own obligations. Whether a similar arrangement can be used locally depends on the risks covered and the insurer’s licence.
Sources: Captive International, US Department of Labour.